24-25 season,  shooting

Shot profligacy

Watching the Devils I often think they are wasteful in front of net, creating lots of good chances, but not converting them. I wondered though if fans of every team think this, and whether it was true.

There are a number of ways to consider this. The league uses shot efficiency, which is the number of goals divided by the number of shots on target. The averages for this over the season are shown in the chart below:

It doesn’t really tell us much, because most teams get a lot of shots in over the season and score a few goals, so the averages tend to be similar, with not much difference even between Belfast and Fife. So, let’s look at a different measure. If teams are creating high chances, are they also getting lots of goals? We can create a ratio of high chances to goals to see. This is a bit of a dodgy measure, because unless I go through every game and see if any particular goal came from a high, medium or low chance, we can’t match the goals with the type of chance. But just for interest, if we divide actual goals by high chance opportunities, it gives us some measure of the relationship for any team. A ratio of 1 would mean they score as many goals as they create high chances, whereas under 1 means they score fewer goals on average than the high chances they create, and over 1 means they score more than the high chances. This is shown in the following chart:

Here some of my suspicion about Cardiff is borne out, but Belfast are the worst offenders here. What it demonstrates though is that if you create more chances you will probably miss more of them. Belfast create 4.88 high chances per game compared with Fife’s 2.02. While they miss quite a few, they also score a lot. So this is probably not a useful measure then. One final way of considering it might be to look at how teams compare against their expected goals (as reported by the EIHL) per game. We can just do a simple subtraction here – actual goals minus expected goals. Any positive number means they are scoring more than expected.

So Guildford lead this analysis, scoring on average over one goal more per game than expected. All teams are positive, so they all score on average more than expected. Belfast are the most profligate though, only scoring 0.28 more than expected. My Feelings about Cardiff’s conversions are borne out somewhat, compared with Sheffield or Nottingham, say. Belfast are interesting, they are quite wasteful, but they create a lot of chances, so it works out overall. That is one way to approach the game, but I think it can be their undoing in some games, for example, their 2:3 defeat to Dundee, where they created 6 high chances, had an expected goals of 5.54, and 67 shots on target, but only scored twice. Fife are at the other end of this approach – not creating many chances and then not converting many of them either. It’s certainly better to generate lots of chances, even if you miss a lot of them it seems. But for Cardiff, they don’t create enough to overcome this wastefulness.

(Photo courtesy of James Assinder)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *