24-25 season

The challenge of the cup

I know this will be dismissed as sour grapes after the Belfast Giants beat the Cardiff Devils in the Challenge Cup final, but to be fair, I’ve been critical of the Challenge Cup format since the start of the season. The structure this year demonstrates the difficulties of the EIHL and the poor compromise decisons that are made in order to accommodate these.

Firstly, congratulations to Belfast, they were deserved winners, and are clearly the best team in the league. That however, is the issue I think. A cup competition should not be weighted in favour of the best team. They might well end up winning it because they are the best team, but it should also provide an opportunity for upsets and an outsider to get a trophy. Coventry, for example, who have put together an exciting team this year, might have stood a chance in a conventional knockout cup system, but had scant hope in the current structure.

The advantage as I see it (and everyone else probably apart from Giants fans) that Belfast have is that they are in a qualification league with the worst teams in the EIHL. This is not opinion, all of their opponents are in the bottom four of the league, with no opposition above 7th. Compared with the other qualification league which contains the top 6 (apart from Belfast of course). This pretty much guarantees a semi-final place. And if they win that, it guarantees a home final. We can argue about the weight of the significance of this, but those two elements represent some degree of advantage. Of course, the final itself is a one-off game and here Belfast demonstrated their superiority over a hapless Devils team.

Look at the qualification stats of the two finalists:

BelfastCardiff
Win %0.8850.591
Goals For Average4.083.82
Goals Against Av1.853.27
Stats for Challenge Cup Finalists

Now you could argue that just demonstrates that Belfast are a better team, but I think it would be a stretch to believe that those Belfast stats would remain as good if they were playing Nottingham, Sheffield, or Coventry instead of Fife, Glasgow and Dundee.

This inevitably means they become the number 1 seed, giving them home advantage. I know the Devils hosted some Challenge Cup finals, but this was back when venues had to bid to host it, so they wouldn’t know they would be finalists (and indeed, they weren’t sometimes). In the same way that the Cup final used to be held at Sheffield (my preferred venue for the final), regardless of whether the Steelers made it to the final.

But given that we don’t have a truly neutral venue, it’s likely that wherever it is held, one finalist might have a home advantage. That isn’t necessarily a problem, but the current system guarantees it for Belfast. The main gripe I have about this set up is not the home advantage, but that it ends up relegating the final to a low grade event in midweek, because the SSE Arena is usually booked out for weekends. What might be a showcase game, with lots of travelling fans enjoying Belfast for a weekend, ends up being squeezed in between gigs. This devalues the event overall I feel.

Back to those challenges the league faces however – the quiet frankly bizarre qualification set up was a compromise to ensure the Scottish teams, who are more financially precarious, didn’t have to travel far and would have local derbies which would generate better crowds. I understand that Manchester didn’t want to go in that group because it would mean further travel (not that they would have bolstered the quality of opposition for the Giants). I get that, the finances of the league are fragile and like a little ember we have to keep blowing on them to keep them viable. But I think the short term gain here may be a longer term loss. If the cup becomes a procession for Belfast, then it loses value, and fans lose interest. Ask yourself this – if next year all teams offered two versions of the season ticket, one that included Challenge Cup games and one that didn’t, how many fans would opt for the Challenge Cup version do you think? I’m not sure I would (even though some of those games were genuinely exciting this year).

I’m not sure what the answer is, but the league has to do better next year. In the meantime, Belfast, lift that banner proudly, you earned it and no-one will care about odd qualification league structures when they look up at the banner in the rafters in years to come.

(Photo William Cherry)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *