24-25 season,  goalies

Looking at the Devils dip

I’m a Devils fan, so apologies for the bias in looking at them in this post, but there are aspects that are applicable across all teams. The Devils have been in a poor run of form recently, winning only 4 of their last 8 games, compared with 10 wins from the preceding 12. So their win percentage has dropped from 83% to 50%. The former is potential league winning percentage, and the latter is mid-table form.

Nearly all teams have a dip at some point in the season, so it’s not necessarily that anything has changed, but what’s interesting with the Devils is that there was a definite moment you could point to when the shift occurred, namely the Continental Cup weekend, and particularly the injury to both starting goalies. Bowns has come back since, but has been playing through pain meds. They moved quickly to sign Taz Burman from Guildford, who has done a pretty decent job, but it’s hard to argue that the Continental Cup weekend didn’t cause disruption.

I blogged previously that the Devils netminding duo was the best in the league, and leading the league in all stats. Let’s look at what has happened to the stats across the team prior to the Continental Cup weekend and since. It’s a slightly uneven comparison because we have 12 (league) games prior and only 8 since, but nevertheless it offers a reasonable basis for analysis.

What’s immediately apparent is that they are scoring just as many (an average of 3.5 prior to 3.625 post), but conceding more – they went from a very impressive, and by far the best in the league, average of 1.75 goals against before the Conti Cup to a more mediocre 2.625 after it. That’s nearly an extra goal a game. Most other stats – total shots, shots on target, etc have stayed roughly the same. The big differences you can see are in xGA (Expected Goals Against) which rises from 1.967 to 2.54, the Medium Chances For, which drops from 17.92 to 15, and the High Against Chances which increases from 2.167 to 4.25.

As we saw in the last post, Medium Danger Chances are correlated with overall win percentage, so that’s a telling percentage to drop. But perhaps more significantly is the story the other stats tell. The Devils have gone from being miserly in terms of the High Scoring Chances they give up, to mediocre. If you double the number of high scoring chances you give to opponents, then it is no surprise that the goals you concede and the Expected Goals Against increases also. It’s telling that the Devils hadn’t gone to overtime in any of the 12 games prior to the Cup but have done so twice since (losing both). Games they would have seen out before comfortably they are now converting to close games because they allow more scoring chances.

It’s perhaps tempting to think this is simply down to inferior netminding. Burman has done a respectable job, but he’s no Carruth, and Bowns has been playing through injury. But while that is true, it’s not quite the whole story. The Save Percentage has dropped from 94.67% to 92.75%, but that is still above the league average at the quarter season mark of 89.94%. Goals Saved Above Expected is the more telling stat and was the one where the Devils excelled previously, and that has dropped from 0.2175 to -0.09. So, marginally just below what you would expect. I think though what’s more significant are those increased chances. Some of these may be down to the netminder, for example coughing up the puck to give a high chance, or not distributing it quickly or accurately enough. I suspect that it speaks more to the confidence and psychological impact that the netminder has on the team overall. When a netminder keeps you in the game early, it gives teams a chance to go on the offensive. When they are less confident in their netminder, maybe they end up second guessing their own play, sit deeper and allow for more offensive chances.

It’s difficult to know the exact impact without a lot more refined data, but from having watched the Devils over these last few games, they definitely seem less sure of themselves. They are surrendering the puck in dangerous positions, not covering players, and then mistiming passes and taking the wrong option in attack. None of that is Burman’s fault, but there seems to be a subtle factor here. A senior colleague once told me that his role was to be an absorber of uncertainty. I think a really good netminder performs the same function in a hockey team. From that basis of certainty the whole team moves forward with more confidence.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *