When is a cup game not a cup game?
I was reminded of the dad joke/classic riddle of when is a door not a door watching the Devils first “competitive” home game of the season. Yes, those quotation marks are doing the work of this post. We played Guildford Flames in the Challenge Cup. Now, I have a lot of affection for the Challenge Cup, it was the first trophy I saw the Devils win, back in 2015.
But it’s also a contender for the most useless Cup format in the world. It has a league format before going straight to semi-finals, as we only have ten teams to start with. That means that much of the one-off thrill of a cup competition, with the possibility of giant-killing, or a lower team getting a good run is largely removed. But, you might argue, that’s what the Champions League does now, although it does have more knock-out games. Still, ten teams, you’re thinking two leagues of five, right? Oh no, you have not taken into account the fragility of finances in the EIHL. It’s one league of four and one of six.
The whole league format is a sop to give the Scottish teams in particular more local rivalry games, and to reduce the strain of travel costs. Still, I expect they’ll make sure the leagues are roughly equal in terms of quality? Again, no. In the four team league we have the three weakest teams – Dundee, Fife and Glasgow, matched up with the strongest team, Belfast. Manchester were a contender to enter this league (where they would have faire quite well one would think) but decided they didn’t like the look of the travel budget either. So we’re left with a league of six teams, which aside from Belfast contains the best teams in the league.
Then the league games are stacked up at the start of the season – the Devils play four Cup games before their first league game on October 3rd. This gives a rather anti-climactic start to the season.
The final is hosted by the highest seeded finalist. It is not guaranteed this will be Belfast (Nottingham won last year), but the whole format gives the strongest team in the league an advantage. We can argue about the size of this, but even a 5% advantage say, to the best team kind of renders the idea of a cup format invalid.
The Challenge Cup is where the practicalities the economics forces upon the EIHL becomes most apparent, resulting in a structure that makes no sense competitively but probably adds in a small bonus to the poorer clubs. If the choice is this format or a team folding, then yes, sure, we’ll suck it up. But don’t expect us to care about it as a meaningful competition.
Unless the Devils win it of course, in which case, great work.
Anyway, the Devils won 3-1 in a scrappy game, with a fair bit of bad temper. Perhaps the players resent playing in these games also. Cole Sanford returned as a Flames player and with the inevitability of a Trump climbdown, scored.
The game was also notable for the Devils wearing sparkly green helmets (presumably to mark the 40th anniversary season). Some wag shouted out that they were Quality Street wrappers and that was difficult to unsee.