Stats and reality
Often the data from a game reveals the narrative that played out. But also, quite often it doesn’t. For instamce, without seeing the game, Sheffield’s away win in Glasgow on the 17th Jan, would suggest a Clan win if anything. They had almost double the number of total shots (63 vs 35), more shots on target (36 vs 24), and a higher number of expected goals (2.49 vs 1.44). And yet Sheffield won 3-1, with all their goals coming in the first period. I’m sure there is a reason for that – bad netminding, lucky bounces, carefully crafted shots, etc. But from the raw stats alone you wouldn’t get that picture.
So, I’m going to take a look at one game and see if the game stats match the impression from watching it live. Obviously this will be a Devils game, but the intention here is more general. I watched the game last night, when the Belfast Giants beat the Devils 4-1. To the eye it looked pretty much that apart from a 5 minute period at the end of the first and the start of the second period, the Giants controlled the game. The Devils looked sloppy, short of ideas and frankly never likely to win.
But do the game stats match that impression (it wasn’t just my view I stress, that seemed to be the consensus). I expected that they would reveal that Giants dominance in some way. But I was surprised to see that was not the case. The Devils had more shots (48 vs 41) and more On Target (33 vs 24). The Tracking sheet gives them Expected Goals of 2.28 vs the Giants 1.77, and they did well in limiting the number of High and Medium chances from Belfast, and area where they usually dominate. The Devils had 4 and 14 High and Medium chances respectively compared with the Giants 2 and 12. The Gamesheet even gives the expected win as 58% to the Devils. It never felt that high.
The Giants had a superior special teams, with 33% on the PP and 100% PK (the Devils PP continues to be poor as it has all season), and Whistle’s save percentage was 96.97% vs an unusually poor 83.33% from Carruth. So you might surmise that the game was pretty even but their nettie had a better day and the Devils special units let them down. While some of that is true, it still flatters the Devils who were never really in the game apart from those brief periods mentioned above. The Shot Map backs this up to an extent with the Giants scoring three times from the face off circles, whereas the Devils had more in close opportunities but only succeeded on one of them.
What the data doesn’t reveal is the aggressive forechecking game that the Giants operated, which harried the Devils into making sloppy passes and poor decisions. Data on completed passes might reveal this, the Devils were, as Pete Russell said afterwards, disconnected.
Do you know what stat does match the eye test of the game? The score. 4-1 seemed appropriate. That’s not always the case, sometimes a team wins by more than is warranted, or a team loses unluckily. But 4-1 was the right score. Who knew, the number of goals scored was the most reliable indicator?
On a more general note, I like that the data doesn’t tell the whole story. As much as I like analytics, they’re an add-on to the main event. Sport remains engaging precisely because it does not conform neatly to the numbers, and hockey in particular eludes simple data driven approaches.
(Photo courtesy of James Assinder)